Say No To A Scottish National Identity Database: Take Part In NHSCR Scotland Consultation

by Ross

The Scottish Government and National Records of Scotland (NRS) are proposing amendments to the National Health Service Central Register (NHSCR) (Scotland) Regulations 2006; an electronic database of everyone in Scotland registered with a GP, containing the names and addresses of around one third of the Scottish population. The proposals would allow the Register to hold extra postcode data, and for some data to be shared with around 120 other, publicly owned bodies. Amendments would also expand the creation and implementation of a Unique Citizen Reference Number (UCRN).

Control Of Internet Speech: How Would You Like This Wrapped?

Control Of Internet Speech: How Would You Like This Wrapped?

This is eerily similar to Labour’s scrapped 2006 Identity Cards Act, which the SNP had opposed. It’s quite probable that this latest revival is not malicious, but rather just misguided. It’s up to us to let the Scottish Government know they’re making a mistake.

Scotland already has an ID card system to some extent. The National Entitlement Card (NEC) is run by NRS who also administer the NHSCR. When you sign up for a card, you are automatically assigned a UCRN. As well as targeting student cards and elderly bus passes, UCRNs are also assigned at Birth Registration and during NHS interactions. The planned changes to the current legislation would rollout UCRNs for all citizens and link these with presently held name and address details. All 120 or so public bodies in Scotland would have access to the Register for checking, matching and updating. The UCRN very quickly becomes a national identity number, potentially enabling unprecedented social profiling capabilities.


Potential example of a Scottish ID Card


This national identity number would allow the state to link and cross-reference various health, education, travel, tax, criminal and other records. Metadata is context. Government could use this information to target people. This represents a significant infringement of privacy. Vulnerable people would be most at risk. The potential for abuse is too high. How long before the database was used to identify political dissidence and civil disobedience? Anonymity is important. Inadvertent or not, this is part of the wider attack on civil liberties and personal privacy and security. It’s also a big step towards ID cards. It’s a slippery slope and we must take action now to defend our freedoms and raise awareness to oppose increasing surveillance.

As well as privacy concerns, there is a danger that this also negatively impacts health provisions in Scotland. There is no choice but to participate, or to drop out of civic society. Some people might choose to avoid the database to protect their private information, similar to how thousands left the electoral register to avoid the Poll Tax.

Far-reaching changes like these should not be hidden away in a short, obscure consultation: they should be debated fully, democratically and transparently in the Scottish Parliament, with proper full-scale consultation, of the public and civil society, a wider Privacy Impact Assessment, and if necessary the introduction of primary legislation. Why should David MacBrayne Ltd have access to my sensitive personal data? What reasonable justification is there for sportscotland to have access to our private information? Far too many organisations would have access, and without good reason. In the post-Snowden era, ushering in policy like this by the backdoor is not a good example of ‘Accessible Government’.

You can take part in the consultation here, or by following this link until 25-Feb-2015:  I’d also highly recommend reading Open Rights Group Scotland’s Draft Consultation response here, or by following this link:

Hat-tip again to Open Rights Group Scotland and No2ID for bringing this to wider attention. Open Rights Group Scotland are also hosting meetings around Scotland to discuss this further, in Aberdeen on 16-Feb, in Glasgow on 17-Feb, and in Edinburgh on 18-Feb.


Further Reading:

Consultation on proposed amendments to the National Health Service Central Register (Scotland) Regulations 2006

Scotland’s Public Bodies

A national ID system by the backdoor: the NHSCR Scotland Consultation

Stop ID Cards 2.0 in Scotland

Comment: Buried in a minor consultation – Scotland’s ID card plans

Scottish Government’s ‘bacl door’ plans for national ID register slammed

Is Scotland Really Creating a National Identity Scheme?

The Scottish Government Resurrects The National Identity Register

The Scottish Identity Card Scandal

Proposals to expand Central NHS Register creates a national population register and significant data protection/privacy risks

#No2IDScotland #privacy #security #surveillance


About RIC Aberdeen

The Radical Independence Campaign sees Scottish independence as the first step towards creating a fairer, greener, more democratic place. RIC Aberdeen are a local campaigning group, ordinary people who want to make a difference. We do canvassing every Wednesday night, along with other events. Please get in touch for more info.

2 responses to “Say No To A Scottish National Identity Database: Take Part In NHSCR Scotland Consultation”

  1. jimkillock says :

    Great round up, one thing to note. Scottish Entitlement Cards are an “identity card” already in the sense they are used to identify you when you use of services such as buses, libraries and student facilities; and are linked to the person’s UCRN already. Perhaps someone can clarify how much they are used to *record* usage, e.g. a bus trip or book taken out but they contain RFIDs so this is trivial if desired.

  2. Andy Hewitt says :

    As much as I can well understand the desire for our national Services and bodies to become more efficient and effective, I’m afraid that the fears listed are justified. No matter how well-intentioned the scheme would be, somewhere down the line, some scroat or party of scroats would take advantage of of the system. No thanks, not in my name please.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: